Modded registry IDs aren't being remapped

Neko2n commented

2026-04-22 05:40:31 -06:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Mod Loader

NeoForge 1.21.1

Mod Version

1.3.0

Crash Log / Error Output

https://mclo.gs/qOLWRX1

Bug Description

Remapping IDs does not work with any modded IDs. It only works between vanilla IDs. My best guess is that the mod is trying to apply the remaps before any modded registry IDs are actually loaded.

Steps to Reproduce

Install RemapIDs version 1.3.0 alongside another mod
Attempt to re-map an ID from that mod
Check JEI, see that the ID has not been re-mapped

Other Mods Installed

I know this mod list is quite long, and connector is always a red flag. Please only take note of this if you're absolutely sure it's a mod incompatibility.

.connector
Abnormals Delight
Accessories
Accessories Compatibility Layer
Accessorify
AchievementOptimizer
Additional Additions
Additional Attributes
Advancement Plaques
AeroBlender
Aileron
Alex's Mobs
All The Leaks
Allurement
AmbientEnvironment
Amendments
Another Furniture
Antique Atlas
Architectury
Artifacts
Artificer's Armory
AttributeFix
Axes Are Weapons
Backported Spears
BadOptimizations
Bagus Lib
Balm
Barebones McQoy
Berry Good
Better Block Sounds Fork
Better Combat
Better Third Person
Biolith
Blood Bits
Blueprint
Bookshelf
Bosses of Mass Destruction
Bosses'Rise
Buzzier Bees
Caelus API
Carry On
Catalogue
Cave Spider Spawn
Cerbons API
Charm of Undying
Chat Heads
Chat Impressive Animation
ChatShot
Chloride
Citadel
Clayworks
Clickable Advancements mod
Cloth Config v15 API
Clumps
Clutter No More
Collective
Combat Nouveau
Comfortable Campfires
Configured
Connector Extras
Controlling
Cool Rain
Copper Age Backport
CorgiLib
CoroUtil
Cosy Critters & Creepy Crawlies
Crawl on Demand
CreativeCore
Creeper Overhaul
Cristel Lib
Critical Strike
Critters and Companions
Cupboard mod
Curios API
Cyanide
Darker Depths
Deep Aether
Diagonal Fences
Diagonal Walls
Diagonal Windows
DistractingTrims
Dungeons and Taverns Ancient City Overhaul
Dungeons and Taverns Pillager Outpost Overhaul
Dynamic Crosshair
Dynamic FPS
EMI
EMI Enchanting
Earth & Water
Eating Animation
Ecologics
Elysium-API
Elytra Slot
End's Phantasm
Enderman Overhaul
Enderscape
Enhanced Boss Bars
Entity Model Features
Entity Texture Features
Euphoria Patcher
Every Compat
Explosive Enhancement
Extra Mod Integrations
Fancy World Animations
Farmer's Delight
FarmersStructures
Fast Suite
Ferrite Core
Field Guide
Flerovium
Forgified Fabric API
Framework
Fzzy Config
GTBC's Geomancy Plus
GTBC's SpellLib
GUI Clock
Gallery
Galosphere
GeckoLib 4
Glow
GoodEnding
GroovyModLoader
HT's TreeChop
Highlighter
HoldMyItems
Hopo Better Underwater Ruins
HopoBetterMineshaft
Iceberg
ImmediatelyFast
Immersive Enchanting
Immersive Hotbar
Immersive Optimization
Immersive Overlays
ImmersiveUI
Iris
Iron's Lib
Iron's RPG Tweaks
Iron's Spells 'n Spellbooks
It Takes a Pillage Continuation
Item Descriptions
Jaden's Nether Expansion
Kiwi Library
KleeSlabs
Kotlin for Forge
Lithostitched
Load My F***ing Tags
Logprot
Long NBT Killer
Loot Journal
Lootintegrations mod
M.R.U
Matmos
MaxHealthFix
MidnightLib
Mirror, Mirror
Model Gap Fix
ModernFix
Moonlight Lib
Mouse Tweaks
Mowzie's Mobs
Mutant Monsters
My Nether's Delight
Nature's Delight
Nature's Spirit
NetherPortalFix
No Villager Death Messages
Obscura's Panoramica
OctoLib
Oreganized
Overflowing Bars
Overweight Farming
Particle Rain
Particular
Passable Foliage
Patchouli
Paxi
Perception
PerfectParity: Spring to Life
Placebo
Platform
Player Animator
Polymorph
Polytone
Portfolio
Pretty Beaches
PrickleMC
Primal
Prism
Protect Your Moa
Puddles & Floods
Pufferfish's Biome Dither
Punchy
Puzzles Lib
Quad
Quark
Quark Oddities
Radium
Reconnectible Chains
Reese's Sodium Options
RemapIDs
Resource Pack Overrides
Resourceful Lib
Resourcefulconfig
Revoted: Wildfire
Seamless Loading Screen
Searchables
Shield Expansion
Silent Lib
Sinytra Connector
Snow Under Trees
Sodium
Sodium Dynamic Lights
Sodium Options API
Sound Physics Remastered
Sounds
SparseStructures
Spyglass Improvements
Stone Zone
Structory
Structure Essentials mod
Structure Layout Optimizer
Subtle Effects
Supplementaries
Supplementaries Squared
Surveyor Map Framework
Swaying Garden
Temporal API
TerraBlender
The Aether
The Immersive Music Mod
Tide
Tide Extra Compatibility
Tooltip overhaul
Towers of The Wild: Modded
Traveler's Titles
Treasure Distance
Trimmed
Tumbleweeds
TxniLib
Underground Rivers
Upgrade Aquatic
Variants&Ventures
Vein Mining
Waystones
Wither Spawn Animation
Woodworks
YDM's Weapon Master
YUNG's API
YUNG's Better Caves
YUNG's Better Desert Temples
YUNG's Better Dungeons
YUNG's Better End Island
YUNG's Better Jungle Temples
YUNG's Better Mineshafts
YUNG's Better Ocean Monuments
YUNG's Better Strongholds
YUNG's Better Witch Huts
YUNG's Cave Biomes
YUNG's Extras
YetAnotherConfigLib
Yori3o's Grappling Hooks
Zeta
Zipline
[Let's Do] API
[Let's Do] BloomingNature
armordamagescale mod
chunksending mod
dried_ghast
e4mc
oωo
spark
tctcore

### Mod Loader NeoForge 1.21.1 ### Mod Version 1.3.0 ### Crash Log / Error Output https://mclo.gs/qOLWRX1 ### Bug Description Remapping IDs does not work with any modded IDs. It only works between vanilla IDs. My best guess is that the mod is trying to apply the remaps before any modded registry IDs are actually loaded. ### Steps to Reproduce 1. Install RemapIDs version 1.3.0 alongside another mod 2. Attempt to re-map an ID from that mod 3. Check JEI, see that the ID has not been re-mapped ### Other Mods Installed I know this mod list is quite long, and connector is always a red flag. Please only take note of this if you're absolutely sure it's a mod incompatibility. .connector Abnormals Delight Accessories Accessories Compatibility Layer Accessorify AchievementOptimizer Additional Additions Additional Attributes Advancement Plaques AeroBlender Aileron Alex's Mobs All The Leaks Allurement AmbientEnvironment Amendments Another Furniture Antique Atlas Architectury Artifacts Artificer's Armory AttributeFix Axes Are Weapons Backported Spears BadOptimizations Bagus Lib Balm Barebones McQoy Berry Good Better Block Sounds Fork Better Combat Better Third Person Biolith Blood Bits Blueprint Bookshelf Bosses of Mass Destruction Bosses'Rise Buzzier Bees Caelus API Carry On Catalogue Cave Spider Spawn Cerbons API Charm of Undying Chat Heads Chat Impressive Animation ChatShot Chloride Citadel Clayworks Clickable Advancements mod Cloth Config v15 API Clumps Clutter No More Collective Combat Nouveau Comfortable Campfires Configured Connector Extras Controlling Cool Rain Copper Age Backport CorgiLib CoroUtil Cosy Critters & Creepy Crawlies Crawl on Demand CreativeCore Creeper Overhaul Cristel Lib Critical Strike Critters and Companions Cupboard mod Curios API Cyanide Darker Depths Deep Aether Diagonal Fences Diagonal Walls Diagonal Windows DistractingTrims Dungeons and Taverns Ancient City Overhaul Dungeons and Taverns Pillager Outpost Overhaul Dynamic Crosshair Dynamic FPS EMI EMI Enchanting Earth & Water Eating Animation Ecologics Elysium-API Elytra Slot End's Phantasm Enderman Overhaul Enderscape Enhanced Boss Bars Entity Model Features Entity Texture Features Euphoria Patcher Every Compat Explosive Enhancement Extra Mod Integrations Fancy World Animations Farmer's Delight FarmersStructures Fast Suite Ferrite Core Field Guide Flerovium Forgified Fabric API Framework Fzzy Config GTBC's Geomancy Plus GTBC's SpellLib GUI Clock Gallery Galosphere GeckoLib 4 Glow GoodEnding GroovyModLoader HT's TreeChop Highlighter HoldMyItems Hopo Better Underwater Ruins HopoBetterMineshaft Iceberg ImmediatelyFast Immersive Enchanting Immersive Hotbar Immersive Optimization Immersive Overlays ImmersiveUI Iris Iron's Lib Iron's RPG Tweaks Iron's Spells 'n Spellbooks It Takes a Pillage Continuation Item Descriptions Jaden's Nether Expansion Kiwi Library KleeSlabs Kotlin for Forge Lithostitched Load My F***ing Tags Logprot Long NBT Killer Loot Journal Lootintegrations mod M.R.U Matmos MaxHealthFix MidnightLib Mirror, Mirror Model Gap Fix ModernFix Moonlight Lib Mouse Tweaks Mowzie's Mobs Mutant Monsters My Nether's Delight Nature's Delight Nature's Spirit NetherPortalFix No Villager Death Messages Obscura's Panoramica OctoLib Oreganized Overflowing Bars Overweight Farming Particle Rain Particular Passable Foliage Patchouli Paxi Perception PerfectParity: Spring to Life Placebo Platform Player Animator Polymorph Polytone Portfolio Pretty Beaches PrickleMC Primal Prism Protect Your Moa Puddles & Floods Pufferfish's Biome Dither Punchy Puzzles Lib Quad Quark Quark Oddities Radium Reconnectible Chains Reese's Sodium Options RemapIDs Resource Pack Overrides Resourceful Lib Resourcefulconfig Revoted: Wildfire Seamless Loading Screen Searchables Shield Expansion Silent Lib Sinytra Connector Snow Under Trees Sodium Sodium Dynamic Lights Sodium Options API Sound Physics Remastered Sounds SparseStructures Spyglass Improvements Stone Zone Structory Structure Essentials mod Structure Layout Optimizer Subtle Effects Supplementaries Supplementaries Squared Surveyor Map Framework Swaying Garden Temporal API TerraBlender The Aether The Immersive Music Mod Tide Tide Extra Compatibility Tooltip overhaul Towers of The Wild: Modded Traveler's Titles Treasure Distance Trimmed Tumbleweeds TxniLib Underground Rivers Upgrade Aquatic Variants&Ventures Vein Mining Waystones Wither Spawn Animation Woodworks YDM's Weapon Master YUNG's API YUNG's Better Caves YUNG's Better Desert Temples YUNG's Better Dungeons YUNG's Better End Island YUNG's Better Jungle Temples YUNG's Better Mineshafts YUNG's Better Ocean Monuments YUNG's Better Strongholds YUNG's Better Witch Huts YUNG's Cave Biomes YUNG's Extras YetAnotherConfigLib Yori3o's Grappling Hooks Zeta Zipline [Let's Do] API [Let's Do] BloomingNature armordamagescale mod chunksending mod dried_ghast e4mc oωo spark tctcore

TysonTheEmber commented

2026-04-22 12:01:06 -06:00

(Migrated from github.com)

I need specifics, like is it not remapping in general. Are blocks remapping, are items, etc. I also need your remapids config. If possible use a minimal settup with just remapIDs and one or two other mods

Neko2n commented

2026-04-22 18:37:14 -06:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Sorry, yeah, I should have sent more specifics.

Here's my remaps.json

And it doesn't seem to be re-mapping anything that's in my configuration. I've got one of everything in there, but I didn't specify any categories. I did have a version where I specified the categories as an attempt to fix this issue, but it didn't work either.

I'll be back with results for an isolated test later.

Edit: I should also mention that the log outputs error warnings for every entry in the file except for the aether:skyroot_stick -> minecraft:stick conversion. Even then, the stick conversion doesn't work--it seems to actually be removing all recipes for the vanilla stick, but that could be another mod, as I have yet to test for that bug with a different configuration.

Sorry, yeah, I should have sent more specifics. Here's my [remaps.json](https://github.com/user-attachments/files/26990966/remaps.json) And it doesn't seem to be re-mapping anything that's in my configuration. I've got one of everything in there, but I didn't specify any categories. I did have a version where I specified the categories as an attempt to fix this issue, but it didn't work either. I'll be back with results for an isolated test later. Edit: I should also mention that the log outputs error warnings for every entry in the file _except_ for the aether:skyroot_stick -> minecraft:stick conversion. Even then, the stick conversion doesn't work--it seems to actually be removing all recipes for the vanilla stick, but that could be another mod, as I have yet to test for that bug with a different configuration.

Neko2n commented

2026-04-22 20:31:30 -06:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Loaded up an isolated instance with just the Aether mod, Oreganized, RemapIDs, and EMI.
Set the configuration to the following: remaps.json

Appears to be looking for a tag instead of an item ID.

Removes all methods of crafting vanilla sticks, except for one?

Does not remove the recipe for skyroot sticks.

Properly removes all recipes using skyroot sticks.

Loaded up an isolated instance with just the Aether mod, Oreganized, RemapIDs, and EMI. Set the configuration to the following: [remaps.json](https://github.com/user-attachments/files/26993852/remaps.json) Appears to be looking for a tag instead of an item ID. <img width="1072" height="453" alt="Image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/54d5aef5-5e16-444e-8b5b-d4ce4d7afd1a" /> Removes all methods of crafting vanilla sticks, except for one? <img width="1104" height="1345" alt="Image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/a0c31ded-d561-4431-96d7-e1ddd326cb18" /> Does not remove the recipe for skyroot sticks. <img width="1125" height="1328" alt="Image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/fdca2271-c90a-4b91-a364-4763f4d483a3" /> Properly removes all recipes using skyroot sticks. <img width="1128" height="1345" alt="Image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/3d5385c6-d636-408f-968c-f900a31b6226" />

Neko2n commented

2026-04-22 20:32:56 -06:00

(Migrated from github.com)

The zanite -> silver conversion didn't load because it can't find the wildcard pattern. I'm pretty sure oreganized:silver_* and aether:zanite_* are supposed to work?

Edit: also here's my latest.log file
https://mclo.gs/xiE6Jwz

The zanite -> silver conversion didn't load because it can't find the wildcard pattern. I'm pretty sure oreganized:silver_* and aether:zanite_* are supposed to work? Edit: also here's my latest.log file https://mclo.gs/xiE6Jwz

TysonTheEmber commented

2026-04-22 20:47:15 -06:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Wildcards dont work for item and block ids

Rows
Columns

Modded registry IDs aren't being remapped #5

Mod Loader

Mod Version

Crash Log / Error Output

Bug Description

Steps to Reproduce

Other Mods Installed